In this article5 sections
  1. Where the idea came from
  2. The hungry judges
  3. The big replication tests
  4. What still holds up
  5. Practical takeaways

You may have heard that some well-known business leaders wear the same outfit every day so they don’t waste willpower on choosing clothes. The idea behind it is decision fatigue: each choice you make supposedly drains a limited daily supply of mental energy, leaving you worse at deciding as the day goes on.

It is a tidy story. The research behind it is a lot messier.

Where the idea came from

In 1998, the psychologist Roy Baumeister and colleagues published experiments suggesting that self-control works like a muscle that tires. In one study, people who had to resist eating freshly baked cookies, and eat radishes instead, gave up sooner on a difficult puzzle afterwards than people who were allowed the cookies.

The researchers called this ego depletion. Over the next decade, hundreds of studies reported similar effects, and the idea spread to decision-making: if choosing also uses up self-control, then many choices should leave you depleted.

The hungry judges

The most famous evidence came in 2011. Researchers analysed more than 1,000 parole decisions by experienced judges in Israel. The share of favourable rulings started at about 65% at the beginning of each session, fell to nearly zero just before a food break, and jumped back to about 65% afterwards.

The study was widely reported as showing that tired, hungry judges fall back on the easy option of saying no. It became one of the best-known findings in psychology.

Why many researchers doubt it

Other researchers soon pointed out problems:

  • The order of cases wasn’t random. A 2011 reply noted that prisoners without lawyers tended to be heard last in a session, and those cases were more likely to be refused anyway.
  • Favourable rulings take longer. A 2016 analysis showed that if judges simply avoided starting a long case just before a break, the same pattern would appear with no fatigue at all.

The original authors defended their findings, but the study can no longer be treated as clear proof.

The big replication tests

Because ego depletion was so influential, psychologists organised two large tests in which many laboratories ran the same planned experiment and published the results whatever they showed.

  • In 2016, 23 laboratories tested more than 2,100 people. The overall effect was close to zero.
  • In 2021, 36 laboratories tested more than 3,500 people using a broader set of tasks. The planned analysis again found no reliable effect. Some looser analyses found a very small one.
If decision fatigue exists in the strong form often described, these large studies should have found it easily. They didn’t.

That doesn’t prove that self-control never wears down. It does mean the dramatic version, where a few dozen small choices noticeably sap your willpower, is not well supported.

What still holds up

Throwing out the idea completely would also be a mistake. Some related findings are much more solid:

  • Mental fatigue is real. Long periods of demanding mental work make people feel tired, less motivated and more likely to make errors. Reviews of this research find consistent effects, though they come from hours of effort, not a handful of choices.
  • Lack of sleep harms judgement. Being short of sleep makes people slower, less attentive and more prone to risky or impulsive choices.
  • When tired, people take shortcuts. They are more likely to stick with a default, put off a decision or choose whatever needs the least effort.
  • Belief may matter. Some studies suggest that people who believe willpower runs out are more affected by tiredness than people who don’t, although this too needs more testing.

Practical takeaways

You don’t need to fear every small decision, but some habits still make sense:

  • Make important decisions when you are rested and fed, not at the end of a long, draining day, because tiredness and hunger do affect judgement.
  • Use routines for repeated choices if you like them. They save time and effort, even if they don’t protect a willpower budget.
  • Take real breaks during long stretches of demanding work.
  • Sleep on big decisions when you can. A night’s rest helps more than worrying about how many choices you’ve already made that day.

Frequently asked questions

So is decision fatigue a myth?

The strong version, that every choice drains a fixed daily supply of willpower, is not well supported. Ordinary tiredness after long, hard mental work clearly does affect decisions.

Should I wear the same clothes every day?

Only if you enjoy it. A simple wardrobe saves time and reduces clutter, which are good reasons, but there is no good evidence that it leaves you with more willpower.

Does eating sugar restore willpower?

Early studies suggested that a sugary drink reversed ego depletion. Later research did not support this, and the idea is now widely doubted.

Sources and further reading

  1. Baumeister and others: Ego depletion: is the active self a limited resource?, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (1998)
  2. Danziger, Levav and Avnaim-Pesso: Extraneous factors in judicial decisions, PNAS (2011)
  3. Weinshall-Margel and Shapard: Overlooked factors in the analysis of parole decisions, PNAS (2011)
  4. Glöckner: The irrational hungry judge effect revisited, Judgment and Decision Making (2016)
  5. Hagger and others: A multilab preregistered replication of the ego-depletion effect, Perspectives on Psychological Science (2016)
  6. Vohs and others: A multisite preregistered paradigmatic test of the ego-depletion effect, Psychological Science (2021)
  7. Boksem and Tops: Mental fatigue: costs and benefits, Brain Research Reviews (2008)