In this article5 sections
  1. Comfort when you’re tired
  2. Knowing what’s coming
  3. Why we go back: what people say
  4. Nostalgia
  5. Is rewatching a problem?

You’ve had a long day. There are thousands of new shows and films available, and you scroll past most of them before putting on a sitcom you’ve already seen many times. You know every joke, yet it still feels like exactly what you wanted.

You’re far from alone, and psychologists have some good explanations.

Comfort when you’re tired

New stories take effort. You have to learn who the characters are, follow the plot and wonder what will happen next. A familiar show asks almost nothing.

In a study published in 2013, psychologist Jaye Derrick at the University at Buffalo in the US tested this idea. In an experiment, people who had just done a tiring task that required self-control were more drawn to a favourite show they already knew. In a daily diary study, people who had had demanding days were more likely to watch familiar programmes, and doing so seemed to leave them feeling restored.

Derrick suggested that familiar characters work a little like friends. Spending time with them provides some of the comfort of social contact without any of the effort. The study was built on the “willpower runs out” idea, which later research has questioned, so its explanation is best treated as a likely one rather than proven.

Knowing what’s coming

Predictability is relaxing

When you know a story turns out well, you can relax and enjoy it without worry. That’s especially appealing during stressful times, when life itself feels uncertain. Many people report rewatching comfort shows more during difficult periods.

Spoilers don’t spoil stories

It seems obvious that knowing the ending would ruin a story. Research suggests otherwise.

In a 2011 study at the University of California, San Diego, Jonathan Leavitt and Nicholas Christenfeld gave people classic short stories, including mysteries and stories with a twist. Some read a version that revealed the ending at the start. On average, people enjoyed the spoiled versions more.

One explanation is that knowing the ending lets you focus on how the story is told: the characters, the writing and the clues you missed the first time.

Much of the pleasure of a good story is in how it unfolds, not just in finding out what happens.

Why we go back: what people say

A 2012 study by marketing researchers Cristel Russell and Sidney Levy interviewed people about the films, books, places and music they enjoyed again and again. Their reasons fell into a few groups:

  • Reliving feelings. Returning to a story to feel the same emotions again, such as laughter or comfort.
  • Seeing more. Noticing details, jokes or clues that were missed the first time.
  • Seeing yourself change. A film watched at 15 can feel very different at 35, which helps people reflect on how they’ve grown.
  • Sharing. Rewatching with someone else, such as showing a favourite film to a friend or child.

Nostalgia

Many comfort shows are ones people first watched when they were younger. Watching them brings back memories of that time, a feeling known as nostalgia.

Psychologists who study nostalgia, led by Constantine Sedikides and Tim Wildschut at the University of Southampton in the UK, have found that it can improve mood, increase feelings of connection with others and give a sense that life has meaning. It is often bittersweet, but mostly positive.

Is rewatching a problem?

For most people, no. It is a normal and often helpful way to relax. It may be worth noticing if you’re using familiar shows to avoid things you need to deal with, or if watching is cutting into sleep. Otherwise, there’s no reason to feel guilty about watching your favourite episode one more time.

Frequently asked questions

Why do I always rewatch the same show when I’m stressed?

Familiar shows are predictable and easy to follow, and the characters can feel like old friends. That makes them a low-effort way to relax when your mind is already tired.

Do streaming services know I rewatch?

Yes. Streaming platforms track what you watch, including repeats, and use it to shape their recommendations. That’s one reason they often keep favourite older shows in their catalogues.

Is it better to watch something new?

Both have benefits. New stories offer surprise and novelty, while familiar ones offer comfort. A mix of the two suits most people.

Sources and further reading

  1. Derrick: Energized by television: familiar fictional worlds restore self-control, Social Psychological and Personality Science (2013)
  2. Leavitt and Christenfeld: Story spoilers don’t spoil stories, Psychological Science (2011)
  3. Russell and Levy: The temporal and focal dynamics of volitional reconsumption, Journal of Consumer Research (2012)
  4. Sedikides and Wildschut: Finding meaning in nostalgia, Review of General Psychology (2018)